Virago Press, 2008
"...there's awful strange things in this world."
-- from "The Open Door, by Margaret Oliphant.
The Virago Book of Ghost Stories combines two of my reading passions. First, of course, there are the ghost stories themselves, and these are, as Richard Dalby states in his preface, "arranged in chronological order," making for a great way to watch the development of the "form of the ghost story" over the last 150 years. Yes -- that's correct -- 150 years. The second thing I'm impressed with is that here, each and every story is written by a woman, some familiar and some more obscure writers whose work I've just read for the first time. It is a superb collection and a definite must-have for the serious ghost-story aficionado, complete with little bio blurbs about each woman at the end of the book. The only downside is that I've made a list of books to hunt down based on said bio blurbs, so there goes the wallet again.
There are thirty-one stories in this book and while some are good, there are others that are downright great and for me there wasn't one bad one in the bunch. I suppose it's all about what people enjoy in a ghost story so I get that not everyone will share my enthusiasm, but I read them all of the time and I think it's one of the better collections I've read.
From here on I list the stories with only teensy bits about what's in them, so feel free not to read from here on, although I swear there are no spoilers whatsoever.
--back to our program --
The book opens with a short tale by Charlotte Bronte, "Napoleon and the Spectre", which is a bit comical and sort of reminded me in a way of Dickens' "A Christmas Carol," but was quite different when all is said and done. This one is followed by one of my all-time favorites, "The Old Nurses's Story," by Elizabeth Gaskell, one which is quite well known and which I've read many, many times but still manages to provide a spine chill each time. That's greatness right there. Amelia B. Edwards' "The Story of Salome" set in Venice also gave me a nice case of the willies as did "Reality or Delusion" by Mrs. Henry Wood of East Lynne fame. Next up is a short story by one of my favorite ghost-story writers of yesteryear, Charlotte Riddell, "The Old House in Vauxhall Walk," which has a twisty ending I wasn't expecting, as do most of her stories. Margaret Oliphant is next with her "The Open Door," set in Scotland, a true page-flipper from beginning to end as a man races to save his son from what's haunting him.
|"The Old Nurse's Story," from Fiction Fan's Book Reviews|
Margery Lawrence makes an appearance next with her "The Haunted Saucepan" which seemed a bit silly for a while until I realized exactly what was going on here, at which point it wasn't at all funny. Margaret Irwin's "The Book" is a great story, one I've read before and one which has been redone a few times by modern writers. Oh my god -- I was on pins and needles with this one even after having already read it and that speaks volumes. Another equally good one with more than a tinge of sadness is "Miss De Mannering of Asham," by another author I've never read, F.M. Mayor. Another page turner, this story is one of the most haunting tales in the entire collection about a young woman whose life is lived in solitude until that one moment when ... Yikes! Great ghostly fare here, for sure, and I absolutely must find more by this author. That sad tale is followed by a different sort of ghost story by yet another unknown writer, Ann Bridge, "The Station Road," in which a doctor's wife going to meet a family friend at the station is herself met by one of the strangest occurrences imaginable, and that's just the beginning. Moving on, I will say that while the next story, "Roaring Tower," by Stella Gibbons isn't the best in the book, it's yet another one that is more than meets the eye at first glance. It's set in Cornwall (perfect place for a supernatural tale!) and finds a woman looking back on her self-absorbed adolescence to a time when strange things found their way into her life. I'm not a huge Stella Gibbons fan in the first place, but there's a definite undercurrent to be unearthed here. Following this one we get back into the ethereal zone with Elizabeth Bowen's "The Happy Autumn Fields," about which I can say nothing except it deserves a double reading and is quite good.
|from The Daily Mail|
|Borley Rectory, from The Harry Price Website|
Coming to the end of the book, we find Penelope Lively's "Black Dog," which is by no means an average ghostly/supernatural tale; like many of the tales in this volume, there's much more going on under the surface than on it. I will say no more. Following that one comes Rosemary Pardoe's "The Chauffeur," in which a woman discovers that her friends' home has its very own ghost and goes out seeking answers. This one is okay, not great but still worthy. Next up is a story with more of a Caribbean feel, "Diamond Jim," by Lisa St. Aubin de Teran, and it is truly an old-fashioned ghost story -- you know, the kind that should be read at night during a loud thunderstorm with rain and lightning while you're safely wrapped in a blanket. "Ashputtle: Or, the Mother's Ghost" by Angela Carter follows that one, and it is one of Carter's best short stories. Again, to tell is to spoil, so ... Elizabeth Fancett's "The Ghosts of Calagou" is another old-fashioned, shuddersome tale set in the "haunted hills of Calagou," where there are legends of dead men "jealously guarding their treasure." One man is about to check it out for himself. Joan Aiken's "The Traitor" joins the ranks of the other sad, poignant tales, related by a a middle-aged "lady librarian" turned lady's companion who finds herself back in the home of her childhood quite by circumstance. Last, but absolutely by no means least, is "Redundant," by Dorothy K. Haynes, about a man who "had always taken jobs that nobody else wanted" and the one he has here is likely the most surprising of them all. Great ending on this one.
So that's it -- I cannot recommend this book highly enough, and as I said, it's a definite must-have for people like me who have a passion for ghost stories over the centuries, especially those written by women. Absolutely delightful it is indeed, and now it's time to hunt down the other Virago volumes of ghost stories.
There is a court case going on in the south west of England between a small press based in Devon or Cornwall (can't remember which) and a literary agent. The agent apparently claims to own the copyright to F M Mayor's short story collection The Room Opposite and Other Stories ( of which Miss De Mannering of Asham is a part). The publisher has been going on and on for literally years announcing this book, which it seems is never going to come out due to a legal deadlock. Meanwhile the collection goes for thousands of pounds on ebay. It seems a shame, as the two novels by Mayor that I have read are among the most memorable of their time I can remember: not smart, intellectual or snobbish, but real and true works of art.ReplyDelete
Hi. Yes, I'm wondering if you're talking about Sundial Press, which was supposed to have had the Room Opposite and Other Stories out this past July:Delete
It's so frustrating to see a photo of the book and yet not be able to buy it for a decent price. Aarrrgh. I wish the agent would get over it, sell the rights and let diehard fans like myself buy the damn book already.
I do thank you for mentioning her novels -- I just picked up The Rector's Daughter (also from Virago).
oh sorry -- I didn't make it a true link for which I apologize. Oh well.Delete
Yes, that is the publishers. It really is not fair of them to keep advertising the book this way. Not only this July, but I remember they had the book with an alternative front cover advertised back in 2014 (!)when I first found out that Mayor had written a collection that was half ghost stories, half realistic stories. The Rector's Daughter is highly renowned, the book where she finds her own true voice, but the First Miss Symons I think is one of the best Edwardian period British novels ever written - to me it overshadows some of the more famous contemporaries. It is done almost in a French, Maupassant pessimistic style. Really a short novella but once read, never forgotten.ReplyDelete
I thank you for adding the First Miss Symons to my to-buy list.Delete
Speaking of Sundial,you are so right!! I wish they'd either print it or remove it from their offerings. In the meantime though, I recently purchased their Rosemary Timperley collection From Another World and Other Ghost Stories, The Alabaster Hand by A.N.L. Munby, and I'm indebted to a friend in Manchester for purchasing for me Richmal Crompton's Mist and Other Ghost Stories, which is not available for purchase here in the US.
I do wonder what legal basis the literary agent in question thinks they have for blocking publication. By every possible criteria, the book has been in the public domain in the UK for several years now.ReplyDelete
I'm not sure how they justify it if it's in the public domain. All I know is that I'd like a copy.Delete